Applying CPR to a dead horse
I was listening to talk radio this morning, and again I heard the now-hoary argument: "What a president does in his personal life has nothing to do with his performance as president."
I'm going to use an example I've used before: what if you knew that the president spent an hour a day looking at hard-core pornography on the Internet? And what if you learned that he had a special "thing" for amputee sex? I mean, what if that's what he liked to watch? What if he began corresponding with one of his favorite "actors"? Nothing salacious -- just basic, mutually admiring letters and emails back and forth.
That's it. Nothing illegal here, and it's purely personal behavior, not involving any of his colleagues or his professional responsibilities.
You got a problem with it?
You better.
The president needs to be trusted and respected by the American people, Congress, the media, and foreign leaders in order to do his job. I'm guessing that if the story above broke, a lot of the relevant stakeholders would say, "The president is an absolute FREAK" (and not in a good way). The presidency would most likely be crippled.
This is admittedly a bit more extreme than an affair with an intern. But I've got to believe there's some zone of personal behavior in which people would say, "You know, I don't care if this stuff IS off-the-clock. I don't care if it doesn't interfere with the president's work in any way. I'm just not comfortable with a guy who does THAT serving as the most important political figure in our country."
P.S. As always, I could be entirely wrong. It might be the case that after some initial shock, people would say, "Well, geez, if he's not going to have the decency to resign, I guess we'll just have to learn to live with him, and work with him." In a way, isn't that what's going on with Larry Craig?